Is professional whitening better than strips?
Reviewed by Dr. Samuel Bacon, DDS (dentist). Last reviewed November 4, 2026.
Status: Approved
Short answer: They differ in strength and supervision. The ADA says over-the-counter strips use lower peroxide concentrations than in-office or dentist-prescribed whitening. Professional options include in-office bleaching and custom trays from your dentist. Whitening doesn't work on every stain, crowns or fillings, so the ADA recommends talking with your dentist before you start. Your dentist can help you choose.
Your options
The ADA describes three routes:
- In-office bleaching: usually one office visit. The dentist protects your gums with a gel or rubber shield before applying the bleach.
- At-home bleaching from your dentist: custom-made trays with professional-strength gel, used as your dentist directs. The ADA says out-of-office bleaching can take a few days to a few weeks.
- Over-the-counter products: strips, gels and toothpastes with lower bleach concentrations. Whitening strips can carry the ADA Seal.
What the evidence says
ADA guidance cites a 2020 review that found whitening toothpastes less effective than whitening strips. The ADA says the most common side effects of whitening are temporary tooth sensitivity and gum irritation.
Why an exam first
The ADA says whiteners may not correct all discoloration. Yellow teeth tend to bleach well, brown teeth may not respond as well, and gray teeth may not bleach at all. The ADA says whitening won't work on caps, veneers, crowns or fillings. See Can you whiten teeth with fillings or crowns?.
At Indy Smile Group
We check your teeth and gums before whitening and choose the method and strength that fit you. We offer in-office whitening (starting at $399) and custom take-home trays (starting at $249). Whitening prices are the same at all three offices and cover both arches. “Starting at” applies to regular in-office and regular take-home whitening; KöR whitening costs more, so call for details. Your dentist checks your teeth and gums first and confirms your price before treatment. Results vary, and whitening doesn't change the color of fillings, crowns or veneers. See our whitening page.
Whitening prices as of November 2026.
Next step
Ready to talk it through with a dentist? Book online or call the office closest to you.
- Fishers – Smile Dentistry: Book online · (317) 570-5480
- Carmel – Simply Smile Dentistry: Book online · (317) 564-8490
- North Indy – Simply Smile Dentistry: Book online · (317) 672-7511
Frequently asked questions
Are whitening strips safe?
The ADA says some strips carry the ADA Seal for safety and effectiveness when used as directed. Talk with your dentist first.
Which lasts longer?
See How long does teeth whitening last?
What does professional whitening cost?
See How much does teeth whitening cost?
Sources
Last reviewed: November 4, 2026
Reviewed by: Dr. Samuel Bacon, DDS (dentist)