How do I choose the right dentist?
Reviewed by Dr. Samuel Bacon, DDS (dentist). Last reviewed November 4, 2026.
Status: Approved
Short answer: Start with practical basics, then meet the office. The ADA suggests checking location, office hours and whether the dentist is in your insurance network. You can also ask friends, family or your doctor for names. Then call or visit, ask your questions, and choose a dentist who explains things clearly and listens to your concerns.
This page is published by Indy Smile Group, a dental practice with offices in Fishers, Carmel and North Indianapolis. The tips come from the American Dental Association and apply to any dentist you're considering.
Start with the basics
The ADA suggests asking:
- Is the office easy to get to from home or work?
- Are the appointment times convenient for you?
- If you have dental benefits, is the dentist in your network?
- Do you need translation or interpreter services?
Where to look
The ADA lists its Find-a-Dentist tool, your local dental society, and recommendations from people you trust. The ADA reminds you that online reviews reflect each person's own needs and experiences.
Questions to ask the office
- Will the dentist explain how to prevent dental problems?
- How are emergencies handled outside office hours?
- Is information about fees and payment plans given before treatment?
- Will your medical and dental history be recorded?
Share your concerns
The ADA encourages you to share past experiences and any anxiety. See Dental anxiety and What happens at a first dental visit?
At Indy Smile Group
We have three offices, in Carmel, Fishers and North Indianapolis. Our new patients page explains how to get started. We're in-network with Delta Dental, Anthem, Humana, Liberty Dental and CareSource. Through the Connection Dental and Zelis networks we're also in-network with many PPO plans from Cigna, MetLife, Aetna, UnitedHealthcare, Ameritas, Principal, Sun Life, GEHA and UMR. We accept Indiana Medicaid and Medicare dental plans. Coverage depends on your plan. We check your benefits and give you a written estimate before any treatment, including emergency treatment.
Next step
Ready to talk it through with a dentist? Book online or call the office closest to you.
- Fishers – Smile Dentistry: Book online · (317) 570-5480
- Carmel – Simply Smile Dentistry: Book online · (317) 564-8490
- North Indy – Simply Smile Dentistry: Book online · (317) 672-7511
Frequently asked questions
Should I visit before booking treatment?
The ADA suggests calling or visiting more than one office before you decide.
How do I know if a dentist takes my insurance?
Call the office, or check your plan's provider list.
What if I'm nervous?
Tell the office. The ADA encourages you to share any anxiety. See Dental anxiety.
Sources
- ADA MouthHealthy – How to Find a Dentist
- ADA MouthHealthy – Common Questions About Going to the Dentist
Last reviewed: November 4, 2026
Reviewed by: Dr. Samuel Bacon, DDS (dentist)